6th Circuit rules against Tennessee registrants in Doe v. Lee: a setback, but not the final word

On November 13, 2026, the federal appeals court for Tennessee, Kentucky, Ohio and Michigan (the 6th Circuit) decided Doe v. Lee. It’s a disappointing result. It’s also narrower than the headlines may make it sound, so here is what actually happened.

Eight Tennessee men were convicted before 1995, before Tennessee had a registry. In 2021 they sued, arguing that applying today’s registry law to them breaks the Constitution’s ban on ex post facto laws, meaning laws that add punishment after the fact. A federal judge agreed in 2023 and ordered them removed from the registry. In 2024 the 6th Circuit sent the case back. It said the judge couldn’t strike down the law as one big package. Each part had to be looked at separately, and the only official the men could sue was the director of the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation (TBI), and only over the parts TBI actually handles.

On the second try, the trial judge ruled for the men again on two issues: (1) Calling them “violent sexual offenders,” and calling two of them “offenders against children,” was found to be punishment. (2) The 1,000-foot rules about where they can live and work, the limits on being near schools and parks, and the rules about staying overnight with minors were also found to be punishment.

Tennessee appealed again. On the labels, the state won. The court agreed the labels are being applied retroactively. But it held that they are not “punishment” under the Supreme Court’s 2003 Smith v. Doe decision and earlier 6th Circuit cases. Its reasoning was that states may sort people by their offense of conviction without an individual risk assessment. It also said that publishing accurate conviction information isn’t the same as historical public shaming. The court said the 2016 Snyder decision, which struck down Michigan’s registry law, still stands. But it read Snyder as being about the combined weight of Michigan’s whole system, not about labels alone. (TBI told the court it no longer shows “VIOLENT” on public profiles. It does still show “OFFENDER AGAINST CHILDREN.”)

On the location rules, the court did not say they are constitutional. It said the men sued the wrong person. Those rules are enforced by local police, registering offices, prosecutors and parole officers, not by TBI. The men couldn’t show that TBI caused their problems or that an order against TBI would fix them. That part of the case was dismissed “without prejudice,” which means it can be brought again against the right officials. The court said outright that it was not deciding whether the location rules are punishment.

So does this matter to us? Florida is in the 11th Circuit, so this decision does not bind Florida courts. Courts elsewhere may still look to it as persuasive. The labels ruling makes it harder to attack offense-based labels on their own, but that is not an issue in FAC v. Keefe, so there’s nothing to worry about there. The important issues of where registrants can live, work and go are still open. (The lesson for future cases is to sue the right parties – we covered that base). And… Snyder (the important case in the 6th Circuit) remains good law!


Discover more from Florida Action Committee (FAC)

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comment Policy

  • PLEASE READ: Comments not adhering to this policy will be removed.
  • Be patient. All comments are moderated before they are published. This takes time.
  • Stay on topic. Comments and links should be relevant to this post.
  • *NEW* CLICK HERE if you have an off-topic comment or link.
  • Be respectful. Do not attack, abuse, or threaten. This includes cussing/yelling (ALL CAPS).
  • Cite. If requested, cite any bold or novel claims of fact or statistics, or your comment may be moderated.
  • *NEW* Be brief. If you have a comment of over 2,000 characters, please e-mail it to us for consideration as a member submission.
  • Reminder: Opinions and statements in comments are neither endorsed nor verified by FAC.
  • Moderation does not equal censorship. See this post for more information

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *