FAC Weekly Update: Operation “Gotcha”: How Registry Sweeps Turn Unknown Accounts into Felonies

Weekly update for November 17, 2026. This is recording number 406.

Dear Members and Advocates,

Over the past week, two more law enforcement “operations” made headlines in Florida. Yesterday, FDLE announced a “coordinated” operation with local police that “investigated” 57 registrants and arrested 13, about 23%. Last week in St. Johns County, deputies investigated 55 registrants and arrested 23, about 42%.

These operations “targeted registrants”. We did not say they “targeted sexual offenses”. That difference matters. These operations do not investigate sex crimes. They go after people who are on the registry. A headline like “23 Sex Offenders Arrested” tells the public that registrants are dangerous and likely to reoffend. That isn’t what happened. These arrests were not for new sexual offenses, and almost none were for anything a reasonable person would call a reoffense. They were reporting violations, meaning paperwork. Someone failed to list something.

So why do these operations have such a high “success” rate? An arrest rate of 20%, 30%, even 40% looks alarming, and it’s supposed to. We’ve been reading the arrest affidavits, and they show a clear pattern. Law enforcement takes the email addresses registrants have reported and sends them to online service providers. When a provider sends back the accounts linked to that email, officers treat each one as a new lead. If any of those accounts weren’t registered, they go out and make arrests.

This puts registrants in a Catch-22. You register your email address as the law requires, and now every account ever tied to that address becomes an “unreported” account and more felonies. If you don’t register the email address to avoid the Catch-22, that’s a felony too. Many of the accounts that turn up are dormant. Others are accounts the person never knew existed.

Did you know that when you sign up for a Gmail account, Google automatically sets you up with YouTube, Google Drive, Google Calendar, Google Photos and Google Play? Most people don’t know that. If you didn’t, you just picked up five potential felonies. Now say you registered that Gmail address 10 years ago and have reported twice a year since then. Five accounts, twice a year, for 10 years comes to 100 potential felonies. It doesn’t matter that you had no idea Google Photos even existed. You can still be charged. We’ve seen it happen many times. Ever had a Hotmail account? Hotmail is now Outlook.com, and it comes with OneDrive, OneNote, Microsoft Teams, Xbox and more.

There’s a more basic question too. Should something like Google Drive be registered in the first place? It’s a file storage service, not an app people use to communicate with each other directly. Many counties agree that it shouldn’t. Many others (like Highlands) arrest people for it. So, the same account can be harmless in one county and a felony in the next? FAC has repeatedly asked FDLE for a straight answer on what has to be reported. So far, FDLE has refused to give any guidance. Take a moment to read through our Petition for Declaratory Statement and appeal (https://floridaactioncommittee.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/FAC-Appeal-to-FDLE-Dec-Stmt-04212026.pdf). This process was started nearly a year ago! We can only speculate as to why FDLE keeps trying to hide the ball. Is it to keep the numbers up?

Overreporting anything that can be construed as an internet identifier is one strategy you can take, but who knows what can of worms you’ll be opening when that overreported identifier is tied to an old account you’ve not used in decades but still resides in a database somewhere. Reporting more accounts than you need to, just to be safe, is one thing. But how is anyone supposed to report accounts they don’t even know exist?

When you consider the numbers of people rounded up in these “operations”, the numbers are staggering. When you read the arrest affidavits and realize that these “crimes” had nothing to do with sexually offending or targeting kids, but just part of a game of “gotcha”, it’s sickening. The reality is these operations aren’t making anyone safer. They produce arrest numbers and headlines, and the price is people’s freedom over accounts many didn’t remember or never knew they had.

FAC will keep pushing FDLE for clear guidance and will keep you updated.

Sincerely,
The Florida Action Committee

As of 11/3/2026 we are at 85% of our fundraising goal for this lawsuit! Help get us to the finish line by making a donation here: https://floridaactioncommittee.org/donations/. You can also make a tax-deductible donation to the Florida Action Foundation, Inc. (a 501(c)(3) entity) earmarked for this challenge by contacting [email protected]

SOME HEADLINES FROM THIS WEEK

SOSA Undercover Stings: Who Watches the Sting?

Has Your Registration Office Asked You for Additional Information? We Want to Hear From You.

Is the Second System of Justice Starting to Bend?

FAC Files Opposition to Defendants’ Motions to Sever


Discover more from Florida Action Committee (FAC)

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

9 thoughts on “FAC Weekly Update: Operation “Gotcha”: How Registry Sweeps Turn Unknown Accounts into Felonies”

  • November 17, 2026

    Internet ID’s are supposed to be reported only AFTER I USE them and only since the time the Internet ID rules were added to the registration statute. Note that Yahoo Mail automatically creates an Internet Tag on your email account and refuses to remove it. YouTube assigns an ID to any comments that you may post.

    Reply
    • November 17, 2026

      Yes but public comments are not the same as direct user-to-user communication and are not registrable.

      Reply
  • November 17, 2026

    Didn’t Judge Hinkle address a lot of this already? I believe his order said something to the effect of an internet identifier does not have to be registered unless and until it is used to communicate with another person. Why would YouTube or Gmail Photos or Google Play need to be registered?

    Reply
  • November 17, 2026

    These police officers must not be God fearing, because if they were, they would know that God will use the same measuring stick to judge them as they do when they judge others. With unjust actions like you’ve described, judgement day probably won’t go well for these individuals.

    Reply
  • November 17, 2026

    We do not need FDLE’s guidance. They need our guidance. We know what the statute says. We know how Judge Hinkle ruled after we challenged them.

    We know, for example, that there is no law requiring registration of identifiers you don’t know about and don’t use (registered after “first use,” says the statute). We know that some of those google apps you mentioned, do not even come close to meeting the legal definition of registrable.

    What is it that we need FDLE to tell us that we don’t already know?

    Reply
    • November 17, 2026

      ☝🏻☝🏻☝🏻 Exactly this!!! Judge Hinkle cleared this up enough that any arrest for Google Drive is invalid. But, when you’re on the registry, going to jail can be a death sentence, so a plea deal is basic survival. They count on that, and they have no repercussions when they’re wrong, that’s the baked-in immunity, and the taxpayers foot the bill and the consequences, regardless of outcome. We live in a systemically immoral state the reaches far beyond the registry. The registry is just an easy target.

      Reply
  • November 17, 2026

    Arrests are one thing but are prosecutors actually getting convictions or plea deals from these cases?

    Reply
  • November 17, 2026

    Arrests are one thing, but prosecutions are another. FAC, are prosecutors actually getting plea deals or convictions from trials for these “offenses “?

    Reply
    • November 17, 2026

      I have on good authority in my County that it used to be plea deals for ankle monitor for 6-12 months, now the deal being offered is 1 year in, and then 2 years ankle monitor after release. My county has many backpacks lined up on the wall in a room, I was told usually the transient offenders on a paperwork issue are released on no bond until trial/plea and come back for their stuff within a few days, but now are being kept no bond and arrested right at the registry office to never return. All their stuff sits their in perpetuity. I know someone who had 2 paper work mistakes and got 7 years in prison. 3.5 years on each, and they said yhey did him a favor, it could have been 5 on each and 10 in proson. For paperwork violations. Original sentence was not even close to that.

      Reply

Comment Policy

  • PLEASE READ: Comments not adhering to this policy will be removed.
  • Be patient. All comments are moderated before they are published. This takes time.
  • Stay on topic. Comments and links should be relevant to this post.
  • *NEW* CLICK HERE if you have an off-topic comment or link.
  • Be respectful. Do not attack, abuse, or threaten. This includes cussing/yelling (ALL CAPS).
  • Cite. If requested, cite any bold or novel claims of fact or statistics, or your comment may be moderated.
  • *NEW* Be brief. If you have a comment of over 2,000 characters, please e-mail it to us for consideration as a member submission.
  • Reminder: Opinions and statements in comments are neither endorsed nor verified by FAC.
  • Moderation does not equal censorship. See this post for more information

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *