How much does the label matter? It does, but maybe not as much as you think.
For years, advocates, including FAC, have encouraged the use of person-first language when talking about people on the sex offense registry. Instead of labels like “sex offender,” terms such as “registered citizen” or “person forced to register” have been used in an effort to reduce stigma and remind the public that people are more than the worst thing they have ever done. The belief has been that changing the language could help change attitudes, encourage more humane treatment, and support successful reintegration into society.
But this new study, Changing Language May Not Be Enough to Change Public Perceptions of Individuals Who Sexually Offend, raises an uncomfortable question. What if changing the words makes little or no difference at all?
We didn’t expect a full pendulum-swing, but researchers in this study found that participants continued to hold overwhelmingly negative views regardless of whether stigmatizing labels or person-first language was used. The findings suggest that while respectful language may still matter from a human dignity standpoint, language alone is not enough to overcome deeply rooted public attitudes.
If that is true, then perhaps instead of spending so much energy trying to find the perfect label, it may be more important for people affected by the registry to stop living in the shadows and start telling their stories publicly. The public rarely hears about the father who cannot attend his child’s school event, the elderly registrant who is homeless because of residency restrictions, the veteran who cannot find work decades after an offense, or the spouse and children who quietly suffer alongside them. Most people only hear about the worst headlines, so those headlines become the entire narrative.
Changing perceptions require something far more powerful than terminology: visibility, familiarity, and human connection. When people hear real stories from real individuals, it becomes harder to reduce them to a stereotype. It becomes harder to believe every person on a registry is a monster lurking in the shadows when the person speaking is a grandfather, a church volunteer, or someone who has spent decades offense-free trying to rebuild a life. Public opinion often changes not because language changes first, but because people are forced to confront realities that challenge their assumptions.
That does not mean labels are meaningless. Respectful language still matters because it reflects basic dignity and humanity. But this study suggests advocates should not assume language alone will transform public attitudes. Real change may come when more people are willing to step forward, speak openly, and allow the public to see the human beings behind the label — whatever that label happens to be.
Discover more from Florida Action Committee (FAC)
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
I don’t think a study devised this way could give a real result. It would take sustained exposure over time, which is not something that could be done with a single survey devised from gathering people to read reports based on headlines. You’d have to expose certain groups to certain categories of these labels over a long period of time.
This study only shows me that those in the US & Canada have skewed beliefs based on an oversimplistc understanding of those who carried the label. If I was a gambling man, I’d say it is largely thanks to trash TV like crime drama shows, idiots like Nancy Grace and John Walsh, and that godawful Dateline NBC entrapment show that has taught an entire generation to think in simple “they’re all (p-word)s)” labels.
I like what Tyrion Lannister said in Game of Thrones( watch if you have not, a lot of nudity so if it triggers issues dont watch it) but he said “Never forget what you are. The rest of the world will not. Wear it like armor, and it can never be used to hurt you.” he was referring to one of the characters being a bastard.
It’s really not all that different than any given state refusing to call its “treatment facilities” what they really are – prisons, just because they call the inmates “residents” and the person who runs it a “Superintendent.” Oh, and the release date from said facilities is the day after death, more often than not. Beyond that, there’s no difference in “treatment facilities” and prisons.
I for one didn’t expect person-first language to make a big impact on a mass scale. It will to many individuals, but not society as a whole. The simple truth is that most minds regarding the registry won’t change until they or someone they know ends up on it.
Nothing will get better until the Zeitgeist changes and this hair-on-fire witch hunt cools down. It wasn’t like this when I was a kid, and if you’re old enough you know what I mean. It’s going to take some kind of cultural shift, led by the younger generation at some point to adjust society’s perception to stop imagining monsters around every corner.
Amen to this article’s message! It isn’t always easy or even appropriate, but there are opportunities to share our stories and change the mythical narrative portrayed in mainstream media and culture.
To be frank, not all of us should be ambassadors. Like any population, we have our fair share of curmudgeons and too-rough-around-the-edges, as well as some offenses that are just so gut wrenching that there will be few opportunities to find a receptive audience. But, pretty much all of us could do better at serving ourselves and movement by improving ourselves (mind/body/heart/spirit), our mood and disposition surrounding all of this, our speaking abilities, our ownership and accountability of wrongdoings, and courage to put all of that to good use. It’s the life long journey we’ve signed up for, whether knowingly and intentionally or not, we’re here. Let’s make the best of it and serve this earthly purpose we now have.
I had a coworker that once lambasted me online because I got the position through a college program and the college apparently, according to her, should do a better job choosing their students. She found out about it after I was let go because of my caste position in society. People usually are more upset finding out after the situation is over, which perplexes me. I’m the same guy I was before you knew.