Judge Walker splits up FAC v Keefe into smaller portions
Today, Judge Mark Walker ruled on the large batch of motions the defendants filed in FAC v. Keefe. It’s not good news in the sense that it means more work for our legal team – but we’re plugging ahead. Judge Walker did two things:
- He split the case up by region. The judge decided one courtroom in Tallahassee is not the right place to handle claims against roughly 45 counties and cities across the state. He kept the defendants located in the Northern District of Florida: FDLE Commissioner Keefe, Calhoun, Holmes, Jackson, Levy and Washington Counties, and the City of Gainesville. He dropped the rest without prejudice, which means FAC can refile against them in the Middle and Southern Districts of Florida. He said outright that he took this route instead of transferring the claims so FAC could choose how to go after those defendants.
-
He told FAC to rewrite the complaint’s format. He called the amended complaint a “shotgun pleading.” That is a technical drafting issue: every count repeats all the paragraphs that came before it. The fix is to restructure the complaint so each claim stands on its own. An easy fix. FAC has until December 11, 2026 to amended the complaint, which we will do.
On the positive side: The case is still alive. The judge did not rule against FAC’s core argument that Florida’s registry laws and local residency ordinances are unconstitutional. He did not reach the merits at all. The main defendant (FDLE) stays in. Commissioner Keefe, who oversees the statewide registry, remains a defendant in the lead case. Also, the defendants’ strongest arguments weren’t decided. Defendants raised standing, res judicata, statute of limitations and other defenses. The judge set them aside and ruled only on structure and format. Those issues can be fixed. Also, every dismissal in the order is without prejudice, so FAC can revive every claim.
Our amended complaint is due in three weeks, and possibly new filings in two other federal districts (which don’t have a filing deadline). We are pressing forward. Just A LOT more work for us ahead!
Discover more from Florida Action Committee (FAC)
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

in short he is rooting for the state and giving it every opportunity for success while watering down the argument as much as possible.
That is not correct.
Sad to say I kind of felt the same way in reading it. All 3 branches of government in this state are in bed together. Until a ruling for SCOTUS. Nothing is going to change. It is sad how 20,000 registrants in my home state can get relief and we cant when its pretty much the same registry and same arguments.
There has been no ruling on the merits at all.
This is what scares me:
“This Court has considered, without hearing, the myriad arguments raised in the pending motions, and Plaintiff’s responses in opposition. This Court is persuaded that the out-of-district Defendants seeking to sever the claims against them have the better of the argument. Likewise, this Court also agrees with the remaining Defendants who contend that the amended complaint is an impermissible shotgun pleading and subject to dismissal on that
basis.
He is showing his hand and will dismiss this case if the “shotgun” approach is not fixed.
Just my reading of what he wrote.
The fix is to restructure the complaint so that each claim stands on its own.
Please excuse my frustration, tearfuleagle, but the post said “The fix is to restructure the complaint so each claim stands on its own. An easy fix. FAC has until December 11, 2026 to amended the complaint, which we will do.” But I think the statements an easy fix and which we will do were clear. I’m sorry you didn’t understand, but that meant the fix is not a difficult one and that it will be made. I hope that alleviates your fear.
How do you see that? Which arguments are being watered down? Where do you see a ruling on any of the merits of the complaint?
This also gives us an opportunity to tighten up our declarations to address the points our opposition was arguing, such as the points from the City of Orlando.
So is this bascially a copy paste almost. for the middle and southern districts? Meaning 1 filing for all middle district counties and 1 filling for all southern districts?
Meaning we could end up with 3 different rulings?
Yes, it is very possible there were could be three different rulings by the three districts in favor and against the claims. Strategically, there is beauty to the splitting of this filing.
My assumption is: Unless they are in scheduling cahoots, they would not be scheduled to start near each other on the calendar.
Given there is only one FAC team and three Fed teams, the FAC team would not be in all three courts at once. I am not saying they will be immediately consecutive on the calendar of each other, but they won’t be on top of each other either. Knowing courts are filled, and it is getting longer to an actual start date for cases these days, each district calendar is going to be different and well managed to each them separate.
Therefore, a lead filing in one district being heard gives the FAC team time to practice their case in one district while waiting for the other two to start. This gives time to gather more info from the first set of hearings WRT questions which could be asked, info needed to bring, etc. I am not saying the team wouldn’t be ready to go, but until the opposition is in place and actually opposing the case in real time, all you know is there will be unknowns. At the same time, the opposition has the same playing field to gather intel from. The second filing gets the opportunity from the first and the third gets the same from the first two.
It will be a loooong slog at this rate, but hopefully will be more refined as each is heard.
IDK if there is a preferred district FAC’s team would like to start in, but they do have leverage here to work. Also, the other two districts will probably have to go through the same machinations the first district did to get to this same point, so this district doing the work today may be the very district which goes first.
Depending on the end results and when they happen, any and all appeals to the 11th CCOA (one side or the other may appeal the findings) could be consolidated into one overall appeal but that, of course, is TBD and a long way off.
Is it a copy and paste for the FAC team? Yes in theory if they deem so, but there are nuances for each district which will need to be incorporated. But then it is also a copy and paste for the opposition as well in addition the need to repeat the same actions from the first filing (I’d think) for each of the counties in each district.
Clear as mud?
The original case in the ND/FL is proceeding. We WILL be filing the amended complaint prior to December 11th, which is 3 weeks away, and all will proceed as scheduled, before the same judge, and with the same case number.
The cases in the Southern District and Middle District would need to be filed as new cases. Presumably the defendants would have the same counsel as they did for round one, so seeing if they will agree to waive service instead of having to spend a few more thousand on serving them, would be nice, but they don’t always play nice, so the case in the Northern district will be the first to go and if there are any conflicts, the court can work around them. Nobody will have to be in two places at the same time, and we have a firm representing us that has 1400 attorneys. There are 3 associates and one partner working on it, so someone not being able to show up for a hearing is the last thing anyone has to worry about.
We (the legal committee and the attorneys) will pick the most practical option(s) and move forward accordingly. When decisions are made we’ll announce them to the membership, but everyone needs to also keep in mind that we have the FDLE and dozens of municipalities reading every word we write and we can’t exactly publicize our litigation strategy and roadmap for all to see.
Excellent! Thx for the add on. When I said Fed team, I meant those being challenged in the suit. I should’ve not said Fed team, but the locals to those districts.
We got this! Thank you for all you’re doing and the support of the voices is strong and ready to fight this fight forward and steadfast!
Thank you legal and FAC for all you do for everyone! I, and many others will be eternally grateful for your efforts to free us…
Keep going, FAC.
A lot is riding on this!
May God grant all of you wisdom, and grant you favor in the sight of the Court as you press forward. Amen!!