Watch where you step! Proximity ordinances create trip wires for registrants.
A recent arrest in Melbourne underscores how Brevard County’s restrictive proximity ordinance creates a minefield for registrants who are simply trying to go about their daily lives. According to reports, a 46-year-old man was arrested around 9 p.m. after walking through the parking lot of Melbourne High School — long after the school was closed and deserted. Police said the man, who has an offense dating back more than 15 years, admitted he was a registrant but explained he was merely taking a shortcut to the sidewalk before it started to rain. Nevertheless, he was charged with violating Brevard County Ordinance 74-102, which prohibits registrants from being within 1,000 feet of schools, parks, playgrounds, and daycares.
What’s troubling is that this arrest took place at night, when no students or staff were present. Yet the ordinance applies 24 hours a day, seven days a week, regardless of whether children are anywhere nearby. It also covers the areas within 1000 feet of schools, parks, playgrounds and daycares, requiring persons to know what path is at least 1000 feet away from the property lines. This creates a situation where registrants must constantly guess whether they’ve unknowingly stepped into one of countless overlapping 1,000-foot buffer zones that surround nearly every public space in the county. There are no signs marking these invisible boundaries. A person could be in compliance one moment and in violation the next, without ever realizing it.
This is not public safety — it’s entrapment by geography. When ordinances are written so broadly that even crossing a parking lot at night becomes a criminal act, we have to ask whether the goal is truly protecting the public or perpetuating punishment. The individual in this case has long since completed his sentence and is trying to stay compliant, yet he continues to get caught up in technical violations that serve no rehabilitative or protective purpose.
We call on Sheriffs and law enforcement agencies across Florida — particularly in counties with proximity ordinances — to exercise discretion and apply common sense. Arresting someone for taking a shortcut through an empty school parking lot late at night serves no one. It wastes law enforcement resources, destabilizes individuals who are already under intense supervision, and does nothing to make our communities safer.
It’s time for a more rational, evidence-based approach — one that recognizes that true safety comes from stability, not from criminalizing geography or punishing people for where they happen to step.
Discover more from Florida Action Committee (FAC)
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Even if he stayed on the sidewalk he could still be arrested. The 1000ft line usually begins at the outside edge of school property, so he could be on the sidewalk several streets over and still be within 1000ft. What if he’s driving through passing by a school or park could they still arrest him? My guess here is they stopped him just because someone was on school property after dark. If he’d stayed off school grounds he would have probably been left alone. Not saying its right, but might have been just bad luck, but me personally, I would never have cut through a school’s parking lot, I was nervous picking my granddaughter up from school few years ago even though that’s legal here. Still feel on high alert though.
This is the reason why I carry my judge’s order which states that I’m not prohibited from being near schools (I live right near a HS), churches, being around minors, and being at a place where minors congregate whenever I travel around the state. I’ve never had to show it to anyone, but I’m not willing to take the chance of not having it. I keep it in my glove box.
Just another insane overreach law that is meant to drive out residents from their county because it’s a ticking time bomb before every single registrant falls victim to it.
I am very frustrated and mad this occurred! I live in Brevard county, didn’t hear about this at all, which probably is based on nothing but harassment.. UGH!
Awww, what happened to the “nice days” of Covid, when they seemed like they were going to cave in an “be nice” and come to their senses that the registry was a waste. Now “they” are more rabid than ever. Heck, they even told us we didn’t have to come into the sheriff’s office to re-register 3 times, which is a year and a half. We just went up to the door and told them our names and they checked it off, never having to enter the sheriff’s office, where you may enter but not leave.
I have a question. Why was this individual stopped and arrested? Was he recognized by authorities? Was he being watched and followed? Was it a random stop by police due to suspicion? I mean what caused the police to stop him in the first place? I don’t understand….. Thank you.
That’s a very good question. May the policies were suspicious about him possibly doing something wrong to the school. Who knows.
How are we supposed to live and put the pass behind us. When we are trying to live a nornal everyday life. That’s just insane.