Why laws named after tragedies win public support
When lawmakers name bills after victims of tragedy—such as Megan’s Law or the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act of 1993—public support surges, but this emotional boost may come at the expense of sound policymaking, according to research published in the journal Psychology, Public Policy, and Law.
The study examined whether eponymous bills—those named for victims—receive more public backing than identical bills without a name or story. Across three experiments, the answer was clear: They do. “Our research shows that adding a victim’s name and story to a bill can dramatically increase public support, even when the policy itself hasn’t changed,” said lead author Krystia Reed, JD, Ph.D., of The University of Texas at El Paso.
The findings raise concerns about “crime control theater” and “lawmaking by anecdote,” where emotionally charged cases lead to quick legislative fixes that may fail to address broader issues, according to Reed. Some eponymous laws, such as sex offender registries, have been criticized for unintended consequences, including increased homelessness and recidivism.
Discover more from Florida Action Committee (FAC)
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
The most recent example of this exploitative political pandering was that Georgia nursing student “Laken Riley,” killed by an immigrant. This was the catalyst moment and main argument they used for the widespread infestation of ICE we’re currently seeing nationwide. Now the immigrants are getting just a mere taste of what we’ve been forced to tolerate for decades. Tax payers are being fleeced for billions all because the outrage from these tragedies were exploited and politicized for EASY power grabs by lawmakers.
They also deflect and offer insulation from all the gun carnage in America.
FAC-3 >>> I thought about going, but it’s to cold for me. I took out the one FAC part. I’m not here to dispute or harm, I’m here just to expose what they did and all that I have uncovered. Read it, you will see. I’ll have a nice lawsuit later I guarantee that. Exposing them today is my duty, my obligation, my oath to the U.S. Constitution. Some will know at the meeting, lets see how long it takes for anyone says anything about it. If you have anything you may want to add you think I might want to change, I’m listening. You got my email.
One would think the people would be numb to named bills by now. There. Are. So. Many.
And they almost always coincide with political campaigns, scandals, and midterm political posturing to take away from all the other awful bills the politicians or candidates for other electable positions, i.e.; sheriff, county prosecutor, etc., tend to vote for or support. And gullible people eat it up.
Spot on.
Named bills are easier to remember instead of acronym bills that become laws as they do today wherever bills are proposed and laws are passed. You can see it today all over. Sure, some named bills are acronyms too, AWA or IML for example, but overall you don’t fear monger with acronyms as you can with names to begin with.
This is why those who propose these bills need to be called out for what they are doing with fear mongering and seeking political credibility for their re-election campaigns or their campaigns for another office.
Well actions speak louder then words. Law Enforcement knows and is waiting for me to lawyer up. I’m real sure FAC and NARSOL are wanting me to put this off now. Well I can’t. You will see why I’m not worried about the 11th Circuit. I’m not suing anyone, I’m exposing them. This is gonna cost them Billions!
My question: Is FAC going to have someone at the HB 45 Committee Meeting on Tuesday Feb 24? Cause I’m thinking this is about to be made public. This will knock the wind right out of their sails.
Yes, several members are speaking at the meeting.
Okay,
These have been informed. I think this will rock their perfect little world! I told them, I think Florida may want to get this fixed before anymore new laws are created to hider our lives.
Man, I’m going toe to toe against U.S. Congress AND the U.S. Supreme Court together. The thrill of exposing it is like jumping out of a plane into a war zone. The thrill of the unknown. Live or Die, I have to come forward to save as many people as I can. As I stated to them, I’m trying to protect FDLE and Florida along with FAC. This is much deeper, the FAC Ex Post Facto case is a Band-Aid against a hemorrhage. Find the artery to stop the bleeding. Find the punishment where it’s hidden. You did help with the 3rd Cir. Less is better. keep it simple stupid. I think we got them this time. I thought about March 5th with the Supreme Court but then Yep to cold.. Let’s get something going for May 17th. That is the 30th of Federal Megan’s Law the one I’m attacking. Timing is everything.
I don’t believe public registration will ever do anything but harm.