WI: Supreme Court Says Online Providers’ Searches of Uploaded Photos Cannot be Suppressed as Warrantless Searches
The Wisconsin Supreme Court this week unanimously ruled that warrantless searches of digital files identified as containing potential child sexual abuse material are constitutional when the evidence originates from a private platform’s voluntary scan. In the case State v. Rauch Sharak, the court held that Google’s automatic scanning of users’ Google Photos for such material did not make the company a government actor, even though the flagged content ultimately led to law enforcement involvement. The court emphasized that Google was not required by law to conduct these scans, and its actions were performed independently as part of its content-moderation and user-safety policies.
The specific facts involved Andreas Rauch Sharak storing child sexual abuse materials in his Google Photos account in violation of the platform’s terms of service, which state such content may be detected and reported. After Google’s automated tools flagged the files and a Google employee confirmed them, a “CyberTip” report was sent to the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, which forwarded the information to law enforcement. Police viewed the flagged files without a warrant and later obtained a warrant to search Rauch Sharak’s devices, leading to his conviction on multiple counts related to possession of child pornography.
Rauch Sharak argued that Google’s scanning constituted a search by the government in violation of the Fourth Amendment, but the court rejected this claim, concluding that Google acted on its own behalf and not as an arm of the state. The decision affirms that evidence derived from a private entity’s independent scanning and reporting of illegal content can be viewed by law enforcement without a warrant under the “private search doctrine.” This ruling builds on similar precedent in other cases involving social media platforms and digital contraband identification, clarifying how traditional constitutional protections apply in the digital age.
Discover more from Florida Action Committee (FAC)
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Don’t look for, download or view underage porn (Or maybe no porn at all) and you will be ok. Having said that, sometimes computers can be infected just from searches for normal everyday items and then all kinds of weird stuff popped up.
Two days ago, that happened to me and it took me an hour to make it go away. Some weird virus detector that I did not have said my computer was infected and it took over my computer. Luckily, after some effort I was able to get rid of it after much frustration. It was not porn but it very well could have been, and that often stays on your computer, even after you think you got rid of it.
If I click on something and then think it is dangerous, I close it out, clear my cookies and browsers and restart my computer. After that I do a cleanup on my entire systems.
What is even funnier, I had norton I paid for, for years and my computer never ran right. I got rid of it and got the free microsoft program and my computer rarely has any issues. Having said that, I try and stay on certain sites and not click on stupid stuff that pops up like ads promising a new car for $12,000 to pull you in.
Be safe, one click could be your downfall otherwise.
All tech platforms use AI to flag this stuff the moment it’s uploaded on their servers. He probably thought he was “keeping it safe” in the cloud. How dumb can you be. Seriously. Dude might as well have jumped in a volcano.
I suspect most of us are ok with google scanning their own services for contraband, alerting law enforcement if their service has been used to commit a crime.
And almost every time, it’s not convicted sex offenders who are misusing google in this way.
This was a wonderful decision made to keep all kids safe in our communities. 2 thumbs up for google. I support this decision wholeheartedly.
I can’t think of any one remedy that will “keep all kids safe,” but ok.